Talk:Noble Phantasm

Might have to be made a category for the list of weapons. Byakko 1 September 2007

Brionac and Gungnir are not in GoB. They are only mentioned in passing (Gae Bolg description and Archer vs Lancer fight).
 * Ah, they're both mentioned there. As I mentionned in the GoB discussion I couldn't remember which was were. I'm setting a redirection for the both of them to the Gae Bolg article then, and it'll mention them. Thanks. Byakko 15:18, 5 September 2007 (UTC)

Ok, now that there's a "NOble Phantasms" category, this article will be removed - when the majority of the Noble Phantasm articles will be done. This can stay for a list of the NPs until all the pages are created. Byakko 18:01, 6 September 2007 (UTC)
 * Of course, things are probably done differently here, but on other wikis (at least, those I know of), a category description should not contain any information itself, just a brief outline what belongs into it. The actual data (such as the definition of Noble Phantasms and their common specifications) is only stored in a mainspace article which is then declared "main" one for the category in question. It's generally a good idea to separate actual information and organization IMO because it eventually makes it easier to modify both. --Koveras Alvane 18:15, 5 December 2007 (UTC)
 * Yes, but I rather do that once more NP articles are ready for the category. Ultimately, the "category" will have only the list, and this article, only the description, yes. I just rather make sure we have a full list of all needed information in either place - here. Like some infodump, if you may. Byakko 09:39, 6 December 2007 (UTC)
 * Oh, sorry for not making myself clear. What I objected to was deleting this complete article (as opposed to removing just the list of Phantasms) and moving its content to the category description. :) At least, that's how I understood your message from 6 September. Also, I'd like to comment on the removal of Magic category tag: since this article is the main article of NP cat, its OK to put it both in Noble Phantasms and in Magic category IMO. It serves as a sort of bridge between the two, then. :) --Koveras Alvane 09:46, 6 December 2007 (UTC)
 * Ah, I see. I'm the one who got confusing (and confused) back then. Do as you see fit, then. Byakko 10:03, 6 December 2007 (UTC)