User blog comment:Skeith9/Heroic Spirits Speculation/@comment-5739199-20140507023222/@comment-24754018-20140508231952

I suppose the aforementioned Sicarii thing might give him slightly higher battle prowess than the other disciples had, if nothing else. Then again, no one is really arguing he has to be a good servant, just that he could be one. Though I suppose I should note my preference for mid-to-low-tier servants is a deciding factor in my very few suggestions (I just think that since most canon servants are almost top-tier, it would be nice to see some less OP ones). I doubt Judas would ever go on to win a holy grail war, but I agree he could probably be part of one, assuming you ignore the Hassan rule (which pretty much everyone does, to the point where I enjoy seeing actual Hassan) or place him under a different class.